Pizza Plus

Discover Pizza Plus, your go-to pizza restaurant at 2253 3rd Ave, New York. Enjoy delicious pies, garlic knots, buffalo chicken, and classic slices. Call +1 212-289-2400 for takeout or dine-in today!

Welcome to Pizza Plus

Taste the Difference.

Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus

Nestled in the heart of New York City, Pizza Plus serves up a vibrant slice of the local culinary scene. This charming pizza restaurant dazzles with a diverse menu that caters to every palate, whether you're in the mood for a hearty slice or a classic salad. Conveniently located at 2253 3rd Ave, Pizza Plus becomes a local gathering spot where friends meet and families share a meal. Open daily, the restaurant shines with an inviting atmosphere, ideal for quick bites or leisurely dinners.

People rave about the garlic knots and buffalo chicken, making it a top choice for those seeking authentic New York pizza and comforting meals that don't break the bank. With an average dish price under $6, indulging in delicious food while saving some cash is a recipe for happiness here.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

2253 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10035, United States

Phone

+1 212-289-2400

About

The Culinary Story

Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus
Pizza Plus

Pizza Plus, founded in New York City, encapsulates the spirit of community dining. With 22 menu offerings, it attracts food lovers from all walks of life. The jewel in its culinary crown is undoubtedly the pizza, featuring a tantalizing blend of easy-to-love flavors. Diners indulge in classic toppings or venture to explore creative combos, ensuring there’s something for everyone. The restaurant also boasts an impressive selection of appetizers, including the famed garlic knots and buffalo wings. For lighter fare, patrons opt for the refreshing salads.

The reasonable prices make it accessible, inviting neighbors and visitors alike to indulge without commitment.

As the restaurant continues to gain popularity, it remains a steadfast part of the local culture. Regulars often describe it as the go-to place for casual gatherings. It is a common sight to see friends sharing laughs over a slice or families flocking in for a quick meal after a busy day. The menu caters not only to the typical pizza lover but also to seekers of comfort food with options like chicken parmigiana and shrimp dishes to delight taste buds.

Every detail, from the dough’s perfect chewiness to the tangy sauce, reflects a dedication to quality.

The vibes here celebrate camaraderie, with locals stopping in to grab a quick bite or chill over a meal. Pizza Plus not only satiates hunger; it plays a role in maintaining the neighborhood's essence, fostering a sense of belonging. This commitment to creating a warm space for shared experiences makes each visit memorable and keeps patrons coming back, eager to gather once more.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-7 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-7 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-7 PM
  • Friday11 AM-7 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-7 PM

Pizza Plus stands out with an extensive menu featuring 22 unique dishes, crafted to satisfy diverse tastes. Highlights include the popular potato wedges and authentic buffalo wings, perfect for appetizers and side orders. For a fresh touch, the Caesar salad and garden salad complement the more indulgent options. Patrons also appreciate the calzones and specialty rolls, including the Jamaican beef patty, a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to offer variety. The hot entrees, such as chicken parmigiana and baked ziti, deliver classic comfort food that brings the essence of Italian-American cuisine to the table. With a lively and vibrant interior, the atmosphere resonates with laughter and joy, as customers enjoy their meals, bringing a sense of community into the dining experience.

Pizza Plus

The exterior of Pizza Plus invites patrons into a world full of delicious aromas and laughter. Bright signage lights up the street, making it easy to spot while strolling along 3rd Ave. A modest outdoor seating area allows diners to soak up the vibrant city atmosphere. The urban vibe blends seamlessly with the friendly environment inside, encouraging conversations and connections. As laughter spills out, it creates an inviting atmosphere that draws food lovers to its doorstep time and again.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

This place is a neighborhood institution, a real family owned place. The white pie with pesto and tomato is to die for. Grandpa pie is great too.

R
Rachel

Amazing NY style pizza, and relatively close!

F
Fran

This is the only place I get my pizza from.

O
Octavia H.

Neighborhood spot to get pizza and more

M
Mercedes G.

Pizza is the best in the neighborhood

M
Mack H.

Love the menu

M
Martine I.